Tuesday, April 28, 2009

A Moment Where I Used Persuasion

My friend was conducting a survey on whether or not child labor should be abolished in Africa. She specifically focused on children who worked in unhealthy facilities to collect cocoa beans. I said no to stopping child labor for cocoa by using casual reasoning. I told her that because of child labor, these children are able to support themselves, even if it is inhuman. I also told her to realize what kind of economic situation we are in. Because of the job cuts, people are going to be even stingier and less likely to contribute enough money to charitable organizations. Although people say that they want to stop child labor, it is unlikely that a majority of these people will commit to this because of financial issues. However, I did agree that no one should go through this kind of inhuman labor, but the consequences of stopping child labor would cause a more unstable economy in Africa.

2 comments:

  1. Hey Piper!
    I think this is an interesting topic to discuss. However I do not believe that children shuld be forced to do work just because of their economic situation. Parents should be responsible for providing for the family and if they can not do that then it should not be forced upon the children. They should come up with another solution. However, I find a lot of your points to be very convinving and I agree that this is definitely a great case where you used persuasion. You made a good point about their economy being so bad that if the inhuman labor were to end there were be an even bigger economical crash. However like I said, I just feel and hope that they can think of another alternative.

    ReplyDelete
  2. hey! Hey that is so true, the whole thing about that yes, child labor is inhumane, but that is the only way they will be able to support themselves. If it wasn't for that, then I guess they'd most likely starve themselves to death or something equally as bad. I think that is sort of a controversial issue because at the same time, I think about it, and like the parents should be the ones to support their children. If the parents can not support their children, then they should not have kids.

    ReplyDelete